Following is a quick list of hotels (and, coming soon, restaurants, shops, and services) in Italy that I personally recommend. I will link to longer information posts where applicable.
I have booked almost all of my (mostly modest) accommodations in Italy via booking.com. Click on the links below to learn more about these hotels from booking.com. Note that I am a member of booking.com’s affiliate program, so every click helps earn money for the upkeep of this site.
Agriturismo Casolare di Nonno Mario. Near Parco Majella and mountains. Owners sent us away with jams and wine!
Hotel Cristallo. Right across from the beach in Giulianova. Basic and clean. Nice stabilimento and lively beach bar.
Villa Diomede. Pompeii. Very basic accommodations steps from the ruins. I went in the off-season, so I have no idea how loud and busy it can get.
Hotel Paradiso. Castellabate. Great spot for a beach vacation in Campania near Salerno and Paestum. Fabulous food.
Il Leone di Mare. Procida. Relaxing, spacious hotel perfect for a beach trip with family. We had a patio (useful for drying bathing suits at the end of the day or watching the sun set). Beach and dinner options were a five-minute walk away; uphill on the way back. A/C worked well and staff were super friendly and helpful.
Belvedere Monte Leano. Near Terracina. Not the easiest to find location. But I had one of the best meals I’ve eaten in Italy in its restaurant.
Colline degli Ulivi B&B. Itri, near Sperlonga. Gorgeous pool and grounds have a belvedere over the surrounding countryside as it dips into the sea.
Experience Milano Fashion. Milan. Hate the name of this place but it is a very chic and comfortable apartment. Great location.
Torricini Skyline. Urbino. Gorgeously furnished. Great kitchen. Would recommend for two families traveling together to book the whole space.
Loger Confort. Turin/Torino. Near the train station, so easily accessible for a quick weekend visit (we went for a Juventus game). Hotel is a collection of rooms on floors in a residential building but the service felt very professional. Large, comfortable, modern rooms with gleaming bathrooms.
Hotel Tenuta San Francesco. Near Barletta. Spacious and clean. Beautiful pool. Big breakfast.
Al Mercato B&B. Siena. Friendly and very close to center.
Borgo Magliano Resort. Magliano in Toscana (near Maremma, southern coast). Full-service resort. Incredible pool. Sits on hill opposite the lovely little town of Magliano and is a short drive away from olive groves and the beach.